The claim: An Atlanta Chinese bistro was closedfor selling customers rat meat
As COVID-19 spread across the globe, racism against Chinese Americans has spread across the country, and stereotypes are making a comeback.
“Better Stop dinning with Chin... A popular Asian/Chinese restaurant bistro in Atlanta was closed down this morning after authorities received a tip that the owner was accepting shipments of rats and mice from a vendor to prepare in his dishes," a Facebook user posted on July 24. USA TODAY reached out for comment.
"The owner and his wife were arrested early this morning and charges are not known at this time. After a full search of the kitchen, authorities found, packaged rats, mice, kittens, pups... So Now U KNOW ! Bon Appetite,"read the caption alongsidean image of rat carcasses.
This claim, and others like it, hascirculated since the early 2000s. It wasn’t true then, and it isn’t true now.
Fact check:Foam tray color doesn't indicate where meat was processed
Consistently rated false for 15 years
Snopes debunked this claim in January 2005 after an email chain with identical text caught its attention in 2004.Right-leaning news outlet The Epoch Times also rated the claimfalse after investigating it in May 2014.
Snopes and the Associated Press have debunked similar claims about rat meat from China being sold as boneless chicken wings. Food and Drug Administration spokesman Peter Cassell told the AP that the story and its attribution to the FDA were incorrect.
In an email to USA TODAY, Cassell said thathoax and the Atlanta bistro claim are similarly harmful.
“This is not true and stories like this are dangerous and misleading,” Cassell wrote.
Fact check:Cannibal Club restaurant in LA is fake, and Priscilla Chan isn't involved
Public health authorities say the story is false
Nancy Nydam, director of communications at the Georgia Department of Public Health, told USA TODAY that the story was false.
Georgia Department of Public Health’s Food Service Rules and Regulations mandate that food be honestly presented “in a way that does not mislead or misinform the consumer.”
USA TODAY could not find any reports of an Asian bistro selling rat meat by any of Atlanta’s major news outlets.
Fact check:Chihuahuas are dogs, not large rats
Image is from a feeder rodent seller
Reverse image search of the photoon the Facebook post leads to aFlorida feeder rodent website. Premium Rodents sells mice, rats, quail, rabbits, chicks, crickets and worms to reptile and bird owners – not to restaurants.
The site uses the same image to sell frozen furry rats in a vacuum-packed 25 pack.
Premium Rodents has yet to return USA TODAY’s request for comment.
Fact check:Aerial photo shows June BLM protest in Seattle, not gathering to demand mail-in voting
A delicacy across the world
Racist stereotypes surrounding Chinese consumption of what Americans may consider exotic foods have plagued Chinese Americans sinceearly Chinese immigration during the gold rush in the 19th century.
In some areas of China people do eat rats, but that doesn’t mean American Chinese restaurants are secretly feeding their patrons rat meat.
Historically, rats have been, and continue to be, a beloved delicacy in many parts of the world including: China, Thailand, Cambodia, Laos, Myanmar, India, Ghana, Vietnam, Indonesia, Nigeria and the Philippines.
A 2013 criminal meat fraud bust in China flamed racist narratives about Chinese food and restaurants. The Chinese Ministry of Public Security arrested 904 suspects for misrepresenting the fox, mink, rat and other meat they sold as lamb and failing to test for quality and safety. That criminal ringdid not involve American restaurants or food suppliers.
Our rating: False
No Atlanta Chinese restaurant has closed down for serving customers rat meat. The Georgia Department of Public Health has confirmed that a story about an unnamed restaurant, which has circulated for more than 15 years, is not true. We rate this claim FALSE because it is not supported by our research.
Our fact-check sources:
- USA TODAY, May 20, "'We just want to be safe': Hate crimes, harassment of Asian Americans rise amid coronavirus pandemic"
- USA TODAY, Mar. 20, "Trump uses China as a foil when talking coronavirus, distancing himself from criticism"
- USA TODAY, Feb. 18, "Coronavirus: Restaurants struggle amid fears of outbreak"
- Diana Love's July 24 Facebook Post
- Snopes, Jan. 13, 2005, "Was a Chinese Restaurant in Atlanta Caught With Shipments of Rat Meat?"
- Media Bias/Fact Check, "The Epoch Times"
- The Epoch Times, May 19, 2014, "Chinese Restaurant in Atlanta Closed Over Rats is Fake; No Bag of Rats in ‘Asian’ Restaurant"
- Snopes, Feb. 16, 2016, "Was Rat Meat Sold as Chicken Wings?"
- Associated Press, May 22, 2018, "NOT REAL NEWS: FDA didn’t warn about rat-meat chicken wings"
- Georgia Department of Public Health: Food Service
- Premium Rodents
- TIME, Feb. 8, 2016, "A Very Brief History of Chinese Food in America"
- The New York Times, Aug. 1, 1883, "Mott-Street Chinamen Angry; They Deny that They Eat Rats-- Chung Kee, Threatens a Slander Suit."
- BBC, Dec. 6, 2015, "The countries where rats are on the menu"
- USA TODAY, May 3, 3013, " Rat meat sold as lamb in China"
Thank you for supporting our journalism. You can subscribe to our print edition, ad-free app or electronic newspaper replica here.
Our fact check work is supported in part by a grant from Facebook.
